Photo: Will Grobbelaar / Unsplash
Termedia says it will correct most of the affected Biology of Sport papers and has withdrawn one, while the editor-in-chief blames an early-career co-author's use of AI tools.
Background
Biology of Sport is a Polish sports journal and the official journal of the Institute of Sport – National Research Institute in Warsaw; it is published by Termedia [1]. Its editor-in-chief is Piotr Zmijewski, a researcher at Józef Piłsudski University of Physical Education in Warsaw, who took the top job in 2025 and is also listed as the journal's social media editor [1].
Zmijewski is a prolific contributor to the journal he runs. According to Retraction Watch, he was an author on nine of the 120 papers in the journal's most recent edition [1]. Graham Kendall, deputy vice chancellor at MILA University in Malaysia, who first raised concerns about Zmijewski on LinkedIn earlier this year, noted that after Zmijewski became editor-in-chief he published 13 articles in a year, more than in any other year, all of them in Biology of Sport [1].
What Was Found
Two of Zmijewski's recent articles were flagged on PubPeer, the post-publication review site, for "unverifiable references," Retraction Watch reported [1]. Four of his other papers in the journal have also been flagged on PubPeer, all for the same reason [1].
The two recent papers are both about soccer. One, on contextual match variables and the metabolic power of elite players in the English Premier League, contains two references to works that do not exist [1]. The other, on the relative age effect and transition rates in a national soccer program, is the more striking case: according to a PubPeer commenter cited by Retraction Watch, it references 16 sources that do not exist, plus four citations to real papers that carry invented details such as titles, years, volumes, pages or DOIs [1].
Fabricated citations of this kind, references that look plausible but point to nothing, are a recognized hallmark of text produced with generative AI tools. That is a pattern, however, not proof of how any particular reference list was assembled. A bibliography is supposed to be the part of a paper readers can check; here, checking was precisely what exposed the problem.
The Allegations and the Response
Zmijewski told Retraction Watch that he "personally did not use AI" in preparing or editing the manuscripts [1]. He attributed the faulty references to an unnamed early-career researcher who managed a shared reference database and, he said, had used AI-assisted tools to organize and format bibliographic entries without informing the other co-authors [1]. He said the errors are limited to the bibliographic references and do not affect the research data, analyses, results or main conclusions, and that he planned to correct the references [1]. These are his accounts; Retraction Watch did not report independent confirmation of how the references were generated.
On the broader question of editors publishing heavily in their own journals, Zmijewski said manuscripts he co-authors are handled by an independent associate editor and reviewed by at least two independent reviewers [1]. He said his decision to submit was based on the research's relevance to the journal's scope, and argued that editors-in-chief should not be absolutely barred from publishing in their own journals [1].
Donata Ziółkowska, Termedia's house editor, initially told Retraction Watch the publisher was launching an investigation [1]. After the story ran, she said the journal would issue corrections for "the majority of the affected articles" [1]. One article by Zmijewski, which had not yet appeared in a regular issue, has been withdrawn [1]. Ziółkowska said the journal's guidelines allow editors to submit to the journal if it uses a robust procedure for objective, independent evaluation, and noted that even strong anti-plagiarism systems cannot entirely prevent inappropriate content from being published [1].
Gert Helgesson, a professor of medical ethics at Karolinska Institutet, told Retraction Watch it is not clearly unethical for editors-in-chief to publish frequently in their own journals, but called the practice questionable and a sign of poor judgment, adding that such editors need safeguards [1]. The Institute of Sport did not respond to Retraction Watch's request for comment [1].
What Comes Next
Termedia's stated plan is corrections for most of the flagged papers rather than retractions, with one unpublished article already withdrawn [1]. Retraction Watch did not report which papers will be corrected, what the corrections will say, or whether any further review of the papers' data is planned. Whether replacing references after the fact is a sufficient remedy, given that citations are meant to support specific claims in the text, is a question the published corrections will have to answer. VBN will follow the notices as they appear.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice; readers with health questions should consult their clinician.
References
Orrall A. Publisher to issue corrections to papers with fake references by EIC of sports journal. Retraction Watch. November 16, 2026 (updated November 16, 2026). https://retractionwatch.com/2026/11/16/publisher-investigating-papers-with-fake-references-by-eic-of-sports-journal/